There’s a stark contrast between people who seem good and those who truly are good.
Psychology helps us peel back the layers of people’s behavior to reveal their true character. Sometimes, what we find isn’t pretty.
Being around someone who seems good but actually isn’t can be draining. Luckily, psychology can provide clues to help us spot these individuals.
In this article, we’ll explore nine signs, backed by psychology, that someone may not be as good as they seem.
Let’s get started.
1) Lack of empathy
We all have our moments of self-centeredness, but there’s a line that separates occasional selfishness from a consistent lack of empathy.
Psychology tells us that empathy – the ability to understand and share the feelings of others – is a key characteristic of good people. It’s what allows us to connect with others on a deeper level, to feel their joy and their pain.
When someone consistently shows a lack of empathy, it’s time to raise an eyebrow. This isn’t about the occasional self-centered moment—we all have those. It’s about a person who routinely seems indifferent to the feelings of others.
They might dismiss your concerns, belittle your experiences or be completely unresponsive to your emotional needs.
It’s not about one-off incidents. We’re all human and can have off days. But if you notice a pattern of lack of empathy, it could be a sign that someone may not be as good as they appear.
But keep in mind, psychology is complex. A single trait doesn’t define a person, so take this sign as part of a bigger picture.
2) Constant negativity
Life is full of ups and downs. We all have our fair share of bad days. But there’s a difference between having a bad day and constantly exuding negativity.
I remember a colleague of mine. Let’s call him Mark. Mark was always complaining. Whether it was about the weather, the traffic, his work, or even trivial things like the brand of coffee in the office – nothing ever seemed to please him.
Psychology tells us that this type of relentless negativity can be a sign of a deeper issue. It could mean that the person is unhappy with their life or struggling with feelings of worthlessness or inadequacy.
Over time, I noticed that this constant negativity started affecting those around him. It brought down the mood in the office and made even the simplest tasks seem like a burden.
Don’t get me wrong – everyone has the right to voice their concerns and frustrations. But when complaints and negativity become their primary mode of communication, it might be a sign that they’re not as good-hearted as they seem.
Again, remember, it’s not about isolated incidents but consistent patterns of behavior. And as always, consider this sign within the broader context of someone’s character.
3) Dishonesty
Trust is the foundation of any relationship, whether it’s a friendship, a romantic partnership, or a professional connection. And honesty is the cornerstone of trust.
When someone repeatedly lies, it not only shakes the foundation of trust but also raises doubts about their character.
Dishonesty could range from white lies to more serious deceptions. It could be about important matters or seemingly insignificant ones.
Interestingly, a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that on average, people tell one or two lies per day. However, habitual lying can be indicative of deeper character flaws.
If someone consistently bends the truth, it might be a sign that they’re not as good as they seem. But remember, occasional lies don’t make someone a bad person – we all tell white lies from time to time. It’s the pattern of dishonesty that you need to watch out for.
As always, consider this sign in conjunction with other behaviors and traits before drawing conclusions about someone’s character.
4) Unreliability
We all have moments where things don’t go as planned, and we end up letting others down. But when someone consistently fails to keep their word or meet their commitments, it could be a sign of a deeper issue.
Psychology tells us that reliability is a key trait of a person’s character. It’s about being dependable, sticking to your word and following through on your promises.
Unreliability can take many forms. It could be about consistently showing up late, missing deadlines or appointments, or failing to complete tasks they’ve agreed to do.
If someone is frequently unreliable, it may indicate a lack of respect for other people’s time and efforts. This lack of consideration can be a sign that the person isn’t as good-natured as they appear.
It’s not about an occasional slip-up – we’re all human and make mistakes. But if you notice a consistent pattern of unreliability, it could be a red flag. As always, consider this sign within the broader context of their behavior and character traits.
5) Manipulative behavior
Manipulation is a clear sign that someone might not be as good as they seem. It’s about controlling others to serve one’s own interests, often with little regard for the other person’s feelings or wellbeing.
Manipulative individuals can be subtle, using tactics like guilt-tripping, gaslighting, or playing the victim to get their way. They may twist your words, make you question your perceptions, or make you feel responsible for their emotions or behaviors.
Psychology tells us that manipulative behavior often stems from a desire for power and control. It can be damaging to relationships and can leave people feeling confused, anxious, and even doubting their own sanity.
We all have moments where we might try to sway others to see things our way. But there’s a big difference between persuading and manipulating. If you notice a recurring pattern of manipulative behavior, it could be a sign that the person is not as good-hearted as they seem.
Again, consider this sign in the context of other behaviors and traits before making any conclusions about someone’s character.
6) Lack of remorse
We’re all human, and we all make mistakes. It’s part of life and part of learning. But what truly matters is how we respond to our mistakes.
I believe a good person acknowledges their wrongdoings, seeks forgiveness, and tries to make amends. They feel and show genuine remorse because they understand that their actions have hurt others.
On the other hand, someone who consistently shows a lack of remorse for their actions might not be as good as they seem. They may dismiss their mistakes, blame others, or even seem proud of their wrongdoings.
Psychology tells us that this lack of guilt or remorse can be a sign of a deeper issue. It could suggest a disregard for other people’s feelings and an inability to take responsibility for one’s actions.
Remember, we all have moments where we struggle to admit our mistakes. But a consistent pattern of unapologetic behavior might be a warning sign. As always, consider this sign in the context of other behaviors before concluding about someone’s character.
7) Frequent criticism of others
Constructive criticism can be beneficial and help us grow. However, there’s a big difference between constructive feedback and constant, unwarranted criticism.
I remember a friend who always had something negative to say about others. Whether it was about their clothes, their life choices, or their ideas, she was quick to criticize. It reached a point where it felt like every conversation was tainted with negativity.
Psychology suggests that people who frequently criticize others may be projecting their insecurities onto others. It might be a defense mechanism to shield themselves from their own shortcomings.
If someone is perpetually criticizing others without reason, it might indicate that they aren’t as good-hearted as they seem. But remember – we all have moments of judgement. It’s the consistent pattern of unnecessary criticism that you need to watch out for.
As always, consider this sign within the broader context of someone’s behavior and character traits.
8) Disregard for boundaries
Respecting personal boundaries is a fundamental aspect of any healthy relationship. It’s about understanding and honoring the personal limits and guidelines set by others.
When someone consistently disregards your boundaries, it can signal a lack of respect for your personal space and autonomy. This could take the form of physical intrusions, emotional oversteps, or even online invasions.
Psychology suggests that individuals who habitually infringe on others’ boundaries may lack empathy or have a sense of entitlement.
We all overstep boundaries from time to time – nobody is perfect. But if disregard for boundaries is a consistent pattern, it might be a sign that the person isn’t as good-natured as they appear.
As always, consider this sign in conjunction with other behaviors and traits before drawing conclusions about someone’s character.
9) Frequent anger and aggression
Anger is a normal human emotion, but how we express and manage it makes all the difference. Frequent episodes of anger and aggressive behavior can be a sign that someone might not be as good as they seem.
Psychology tells us that uncontrolled anger can be indicative of underlying issues like frustration, stress, or even personality disorders. It can strain relationships and create a hostile environment for those around.
If someone frequently resorts to anger and aggression, even in minor situations, it might be cause for concern. Remember, it’s not about the occasional outburst – we all lose our temper sometimes. But a consistent pattern of anger and aggression could be a red flag.
The most important thing to understand is that these signs aren’t definitive proof of a bad person. They are indicators to watch out for. People are complex and can change over time. Always approach with understanding, but also prioritize your own wellbeing when necessary.
Final thoughts: Human complexity
Diving into the intricacies of human behavior is a complex journey, filled with nuances and gray areas. It’s crucial to remember that people are not simply ‘good’ or ‘bad’. We all have the capacity for both, often influenced by our circumstances, experiences, and choices.
Psychology offers us valuable insights into understanding these behaviors. But it’s equally important to remember that these signs are not definitive labels of a person’s character. They are indicators, patterns to observe, and potential red flags to be aware of.
Renowned psychologist Carl Rogers once said, “The curious paradox is that when I accept myself just as I am, then I can change.” This acceptance extends to others too. Recognizing these signs in someone doesn’t mean we should condemn or isolate them. It means understanding them better and, if necessary, protecting ourselves from potential harm.
So as you navigate your relationships, keep these signs in mind. But also remember the power of empathy, understanding, and open conversation in revealing the true nature of people around us.
Struggling with Love and Intimacy?
Many of us find ourselves trapped in patterns that hinder our relationships, feeling stuck in cycles of codependency, unmet needs, or misunderstanding.
The Love and Intimacy Masterclass with Rudá Iandê offers a transformative approach to breaking free from these damaging cycles.
Through insightful exercises and the Out of the Box technique, this masterclass guides you towards cultivating personal magnetism, overcoming destructive patterns, and embracing healthier, more fulfilling relationships.
Don’t let past patterns dictate your future.
